Threat Appeals in Road Safety TV Advertisements and their Impact on Youth: An Experimental Study
Author(s)
Hebatalla EL Semary , Mai AL Khaja ,
Download Full PDF Pages: 58-75 | Views: 747 | Downloads: 213 | DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.3565463
Abstract
Due to long-standing reliance upon negative, fear-based appeals in road safety advertising, this study attempts to examine the effectiveness of threat appeals in persuading Emirati road users to change their attitudes and behaviour in the short and long run. To measure the effectiveness of the threat advertising message, a quasi-experiment was designed, including two groups of Emirati students. Each group is composed of 100 Emirati students selected from two universities. Students were asked to complete a questionnaire at varying time intervals.as the persuasive effects of an advertising message may vary over time. On the other hand, 6 focus groups were constituted. Seven issues related to the impact of road safety ads on young Emiratis were raised and discussed and students proposed a number of suggestions that could help in making road safety awareness more efficient. The findings showed that road safety ads based on threat appeals have positive effects in the short term, but these effects diminish over time. Evidence suggests that threat appeals may influence females rather than males, despite the fact that many of these messages intend to target male road users
Keywords
Threat appeals- Road Safety Advertisements- Emirati Youth-Quasi-experiment
References
i. Colin D. Mathers, Dejan Loncar (2005) Updated projections of global mortality and burden of disease, 2002-2030: data sources, methods and results, World Health Organization October 2005 , pp.5-8
ii. Ministry of Interior’s Directorate Traffic, Road traffic accident Statistical Annual Report 2015, Abu Dhabi, UAE
iii. Ministry of Interior’s Directorate Traffic, Road traffic accident Statistical Annual Report 2010, Abu Dhabi, UAE
iv. Al Rashidi A.(2009) Assessing the effectiveness of Road awareness campaigns, Nauf University for Traffic Sciences, Research Center, Riyadh,Saudi Arabia, pp.521-569
v. Witte K. (1992) Putting the fear back into fear appeals: The extended Parallel Process Model, Communication Monographs, Vol.59, pp.329-349
vi. Williams K. C.(2012) Fear appeal theory, Research in Business & Economics Journal;Mar2012, Vol. 5, p1
vii. Borg M., Cicotte D., Finks C. & Mercado C. (2000) Using Fear to Reach Military Members: A Content-analytic Study of Defense Department PSAs, University of Oklahoma, December
viii. Williams, op.cit, pp.7-8
ix. Witte K. & Allen M.(2000) A Meta-Analysis of Fear Appeals: Implications for Effective Public Health Campaigns, Health Education and Behavior,Vol.27 (5), October ,pp.591-615
x. Tannenbaum M. B., Hepler J.,Zimmerman R.,Saul and Jacobs, Wilson & Albarracin (2015)Appealing to Fear:A meta analysis of Fear Appeal Effectiveness and Theories, Psychological Bulletin , Vol.4, (6), 1178-1204
xi. Sarrina Li, Shu-Chu (2014)Fear Appeals and College Students’ Attitudes and Behavioral Intentions Toward Global Warming, The Journal of Environmental Education, Vol. 45 (4)
xii. Peters G., Ruiter R. & Kok G.(2018 )Threatening communication: a qualitative study of fear appeal Threatening communication: a qualitative study of fear appeal effectiveness beliefs among intervention developers, policy makers , politicians, scientists and advertising professionals, International Journal of Psychology Vol 49 (2), pp. 71-79 .
xiii. A’Alam, S.(1999) Studies in Traffic Media in Egypt and GCC, second edition, Dar al Thakafa Al Arabia, p. 74-76
xiv. Williams, op.cit, 9-11
xv. Witte K (1994) Fear control and danger control: A test of the extended parallel process model (EPPM). Communications Monographs 61: 113–134
xvi. Lewis IM, Watson B, White KM (2010) Response efficacy: the key to minimizing rejection and maximizing acceptance of emotion-based anti-speeding messages. Accident Analysis & Prevention 42: 459–467
xvii. Bener A. & Crundall D. (2005) Road Traffic Accidents in the United Arab Emirates compared to Western countries, Advances in transportation studies an international journal section A6,
xviii. Hammoudi A., Karani, G., & Littlewood J. (2014) Road traffic Accidents among Drivers in Abu Dhabi, United Arab Emirates, Journal of Traffic and Logistic Engineering, Vol. 2, No. 1, March
xix. Ali Humaid Al Darei (2009) evaluation of the effectiveness of speed Cameras on road safety in the Emirate of Abu Dhabi roads, MS Thesis in civil engineering, UAEU, June 2009
xx. Griffin, E., Ledbetter, A. & Sparks, G.(2014) , A First Look at Communication Theory, 9th edition, McGraw Hill
xxi. Rosengren,K. & Windahl S (1989).Media Matter: TV use in childhood and Adolescence , USA, Ablex Publishing Corporation
Cite this Article: